Skip to main content

Featured post

Why GeM bids get rejected even if you are L1 ? -----If we are technically qualified, our financial bid will be opened, if we are L1 why they will be checking again technically ?

This post is dedicated to Ma’am, ( kalavathi kolanu) your question regarding my previous post' Why GeM bids get rejected even if you are L1? along with your request for a practical example. I appreciate your curiosity and engagement. As requested, I have shared an example here to provide a clearer understanding of the concept. _________________________________________________________________________________   Checking the bid evaluation order with the user. You are right for a normal two-packet GeM bid, and you are not wrong either. The buyer opens your financial bid only if you passed the technical evaluation. A technically rejected seller’s price is not visible to the buyer (GeM FAQ). So if you are L1 in the financial evaluation, you have already passed the technical check. The buyer does not do a routine second technical check just because you are L1. You can tell them: In a normal two-packet bid, technical comes first and only qualified sellers’ financial bids are opened. So...

Why GeM bids get rejected even if you are L1 ? -----If we are technically qualified, our financial bid will be opened, if we are L1 why they will be checking again technically ?

This post is dedicated to Ma’am, ( kalavathi kolanu) your question regarding my previous post'

Why GeM bids get rejected even if you are L1?

along with your request for a practical example.

I appreciate your curiosity and engagement. As requested, I have shared an example here to provide a clearer understanding of the concept.

_________________________________________________________________________________

 Checking the bid evaluation order with the user.

You are right for a normal two-packet GeM bid, and you are not wrong either. The buyer opens your financial bid only if you passed the technical evaluation. A technically rejected seller’s price is not visible to the buyer (GeM FAQ). So if you are L1 in the financial evaluation, you have already passed the technical check. The buyer does not do a routine second technical check just because you are L1.

You can tell them:

In a normal two-packet bid, technical comes first and only qualified sellers’ financial bids are opened. So an L1 seller has already passed technical. The reasons an L1 seller still loses the order are different: MSE/MII purchase preference, price negotiation or reverse auction, an unrealistically low price that the buyer questions, the buyer cancelling the bid, or missing the ePBG or other deadlines after the award.

There are only a few narrow exceptions where an L1 seller’s documents can be questioned again:

  • Single-packet bids: Technical and price are submitted together, so GeM lets the buyer pick L1 bidders for technical evaluation after prices are visible. I have not seen the official rule text, so check the bid type.
  • False or misleading declarations found later: In an Allahabad High Court case, an L1 seller was rejected after a rival complained that its affidavit was false. That was a UP state e-tender, not stated to be on GeM.
  • Suspension: A seller suspended at the time of technical bid opening is automatically disqualified. A GeM overview deck also lists a feature on the effect of suspension at the time of award, but I could not read the details.

Yes, it can happen even after the technical check and the financial bid both pass. 

These two real GeM bids show it, and you can look them up by number.

Example 1: L1 on GeM, but an MSE took the order (SAIL, 2026)

  • Bid: GeM bid GEM/2025/B/6974725 (8 Dec 2025), reverse auction GEM/2026/R/631912.
  • What passed: United Air Express was technically qualified, reached the financial stage, and was L1 at about ₹155.27 crore.
  • What went wrong: The tender said that if L1 is a non-MSE, 100% of the order goes to an MSE within L1 + 15% that matches the L1 price. An MSE (Metal Traders Processing Co.) was L3, only about ₹7 lakh above L1.
  • Outcome: SAIL issued the work order to the L1 seller without giving the MSE the chance to match. The Calcutta High Court (17 Sep 2026) ordered that the MSE be invited to match and that the L1’s work order be recalled if it could. The MSE consented to match.

A simple version of the same rule: L1 is ₹10 lakh and not an MSE. An MSE quotes ₹11.2 lakh, which is inside the ₹11.5 lakh limit (L1 + 15%). If it agrees to ₹10 lakh, it can get the order instead of you.

Example 2: L1, then rejected for an unrealistically low price (UIDAI, GeM bid)

  • Bid: GeM bid GEM/2022/B/2690078.
  • What passed: The seller had the highest technical score and was declared L1 on 7 Jul 2023 after the financial bids were opened.
  • What went wrong: Other bidders objected that its rate for one packet (₹1.92) was abnormally low. The buyer asked it to justify the price twice. The evaluation committee was not satisfied and did not consider its bid, and the contract went to another bidder.
  • Outcome: The Delhi High Court (14 Oct 2025) did not overturn the decision. This was a quality-and-cost bid where other agencies had to match the L1 rate, so not every GeM bid works this way.

So the Mam is right that no routine technical re-check happens for an L1 seller. The order can still be lost to MSE/MII preference, a price the buyer questions, a cancelled bid, or missed deadlines after the award. Rules differ by bid, so read the bid document and ATC.

but as well as 

I'll look for real, documented cases where an L1 seller on GeM still did not get the order, starting with the Calcutta High Court case I came across earlier.

Yes, there are documented cases, and they are more useful than my earlier general list. I read three court judgments in full and found a fourth in search results. They show L1 sellers who did not get the order, and in none of them was the reason a second technical check.

Case Portal What happened to the L1 seller Reason
SAIL / United Air Express (Calcutta HC, 17 Sep 2026) GeM Order challenged and sent back for an MSE price-match MSE purchase preference
Writer Business Services v UIDAI (Delhi HC, 14 Oct 2025) GeM Rejected after being declared L1 "Abnormally low" price
Energo Constructions v UPRVUNL (Allahabad HC, 21 Feb 2024) State e-tender, not stated as GeM Disqualified after the financial bid was opened False affidavit
Global Services (Chhattisgarh HC, 2026) Non-GeM state portal No order issued Tender cancelled

1. L1, but an MSE took the order (GeM, 2026)

This is the most recent case and the most relevant to GeM sellers.

  • The bid: GeM bid GEM/2025/B/6974725 (8 Dec 2025) by SAIL's IISCO Steel Plant for handling and processing scrap and slag. A reverse auction followed.
  • The ranking: After the reverse auction, United Air Express (non-MSE) was L1 at about ₹155.27 crore. FSNL was L2. Metal Traders Processing Co., an MSE, was L3 at about ₹155.34 crore.
  • The tender term: The bid could not be split. If L1 was a non-MSE and preference applied, 100% of the order would go to an eligible MSE within L1 + 15% that matched the L1 price.
  • The glitch: The GeM portal had no price-matching option for this bid. GeM told SAIL to do the matching offline. SAIL did not, and issued the work order to L1.
  • The result: The Calcutta High Court directed SAIL to invite the MSE to match the L1 price. If the MSE could match, the L1's work order was to be recalled. The Division Bench upheld this on 17 Sep 2026. The MSE gave unconditional consent to match on 2 Sep 2026. The court left the L1's claim for mobilisation costs to a civil court.

Lesson: If you are L1 and not an MSE, check whether the bid has MSE/MII preference. An MSE within the price band can take part or all of your order if it matches your price.

2. L1, then rejected for an "abnormally low" price (GeM, 2023 bid)

  • The bid: GeM RFP GEM/2022/B/2690078 by UIDAI, evaluated on quality and cost (QCBS).
  • How the seller became L1: The petitioner had the highest technical score (96.5) and was declared L1 on 7 Jul 2023.
  • What happened next: Other bidders objected to its rate for the digital verification packet (₹1.92 per packet, which the authority described as about 58% lower than the other packet's rate). The authority asked the petitioner to justify the price twice. The evaluation committee was not satisfied and did not consider the bid. The contract went to another bidder.
  • The court: The Delhi High Court said the authority had not followed the RFP clauses correctly. It still declined to interfere, because no other bidder would match the rate and the authority had given the seller two chances to explain.

Lesson: Be ready to justify your price in writing. Note that this was a quality-and-cost bid where several agencies had to match L1's rate, so not every GeM bid works this way.

3. L1 after the financial bid opened, then disqualified (2024)

  • The bid: A UP power company's tender for operating a coal handling plant. The court judgment does not say it was on GeM.
  • The ranking: Energo Constructions passed the technical stage and was L1 at about ₹28.42 crore.
  • The complaint: A rival complained that Energo had made a false declaration on its notarized affidavit about earlier blacklisting or contract termination. The buyer rejected the L1 bid during financial evaluation, and the contract went to L2.
  • The court: The Allahabad High Court dismissed the petition and said being L1 was immaterial.

Lesson: Documents that were accepted at the technical stage can be challenged later, for example by a rival's complaint. A false declaration can cost you the order after you have been ranked L1.

4. L1 but the tender was cancelled

In a Chhattisgarh municipal tender, the petitioner was technically qualified and became L-1 when the financial bids were opened on 30 January 2026. The authorities cancelled the process on 17 March 2026 because the tender was issued on the state portal instead of GeM. The High Court ruled that being declared L1 does not give a vested right to the contract. This was not a GeM bid, but it shows that L1 status alone does not guarantee an order.

What this means for your question

You were right that in a normal two-packet GeM bid, the buyer does not re-check technical eligibility just because you are L1. The real cases show other ways an L1 loses the order:

  • an MSE or Make in India preference
  • a price the buyer finds too low
  • a false or misleading declaration discovered later
  • a cancelled tender

I am not a lawyer, and each bid's terms decide the outcome. Always read the bid document and ATC.

THANKS




Comments

MUST READ

What is L1 comparison in GeM? How to make l1 comparrision in gem below 10 lakh ?

What is L1 Comparison in GeM? L1 Comparison on the GeM (Government e-Marketplace) portal refers to the process of identifying the Lowest One (L1) price among products or services that meet the same specifications and requirements. This ensures that the government procures goods and services at the most competitive prices. How to Make L1 Comparison in GeM Below 10 Lakh For purchases below INR 10 lakh, the process involves a few key steps: Login to GeM Portal : Go to gem.gov.in and log in with your credentials. Select Product Category : Choose the product or service category you are interested in. Search for Products : Enter the product specifications and search for available options. Add to Comparison : Select at least three products from different OEMs (Original Equipment Manufacturers) or service providers that meet the required specifications. Click on the “Compare” button to add these products to the comparison list. Evaluate Products : Compare the products based on price, quality...

HOW TO MAKE L1 COMPARISION OF A PRODUCT OR SERVICES WITH NEW UPDATES IN GEM PORTAL? STEP BY STEP

  To make an L1 (Lowest One) comparison of a product or service on the GeM (Government e-Marketplace) portal, follow these steps: Step-by-Step Guide for L1 Comparison on GeM Login to GeM Portal : Navigate to the GeM website. Click on the Login button at the top right corner. Enter your User ID and Password to log in. Navigate to the Marketplace : Once logged in, click on the Market link to access the GeM Marketplace. You can also directly access it from the homepage. Select the Category : Enter the category name or keywords related to your product or service. Choose the appropriate category from the list. Apply Filters : On the left-hand side, you will see a section called Filter with options like Administrative , Financial , Make/Model Selection , and Product Specifications . Focus on the Product Specifications section. You will see two types of filters: Golden Parameters (yellow) and Silver Parameters (gray). Select the right combination of Golden Parameters for your pro...

**GeM (Government e-Marketplace) Portal: Key Changes in 2026 (up to June 2026)**

 **GeM (Government e-Marketplace) Portal: Key Changes in 2026 (up to June 2026)** regarding products, services, manpower, and L1-related processes. https://lnkd.in/gq3UBEMe https://lnkd.in/d2fV6-Uy GeM is India's national procurement platform for government buyers. In 2026, it has seen ongoing updates for transparency, MSME support, digital features, expanded categories, and refined bidding rules. Procurement volume continues to grow significantly (already crossing high figures in FY26). Changes are evolutionary rather than revolutionary, focusing on compliance, new green/tech categories, and streamlining. ### 1. Products: New Categories, Listing & Procurement Rules - **New/Expanded Categories (2026)**: Significant additions to support government priorities like sustainability and tech:   - EV (Electric Vehicles) products, charging equipment, batteries, and related maintenance.   - Solar energy products (panels, inverters, installation).   - Green building materi...